Skip to main content
    Leadership

    Digital Transformation Is a Leadership Problem With an IT Budget

    Why strategic leadership decides whether digital transformation succeeds, and why the technology is the easy part.

    Daniel MartiDaniel Marti·7 min read
    Digital Transformation Is a Leadership Problem With an IT Budget – Leadership and transformation
    In short: Digital transformation rarely fails on technology. In a global McKinsey survey, only 16 percent of respondents said their digital transformation had improved performance and made the change stick. The gap is a leadership gap. Leaders delegate an adaptive challenge (how people work, decide and share power) as if it were a technical project. Successful digital transformation needs leadership that steers the product side and the human side at the same time.

    The steering committee meets every month. Every milestone is green. The new ERP is live, the CRM has been rolled out, the collaboration platform reports healthy log-in numbers.

    And yet the sales team still keeps its pipeline in a spreadsheet on somebody's desktop. Decisions still wait for the Thursday meeting. And the customer still gets three different answers from three departments.

    Project people call this watermelon reporting: green on the outside, red on the inside.

    The fast caterpillar

    MIT's George Westerman has an image for it. Done right, digital transformation is like a caterpillar turning into a butterfly. Done wrong, you get a very fast caterpillar.

    Most digital transformations produce fast caterpillars. They digitise the existing process, the existing hierarchy and the existing way of deciding. Then they wonder why nothing has changed except the software licence bill.

    The numbers are sobering. In McKinsey's 2018 global survey on digital transformations, only 16 percent of respondents said their transformation had improved performance and equipped the organisation to sustain the change in the long term. In traditional industries, success rates ranged between 4 and 11 percent.

    One finding from the same survey deserves more attention in Switzerland. Respondents from organisations with fewer than 100 employees were 2.7 times more likely to report a successful transformation than those from organisations with more than 50,000. Size isn't destiny. But the shorter the distance between leadership and the work, the better the odds. For Swiss SMEs, that's good news. If their leaders use that proximity.

    Technical problem or adaptive challenge?

    Ronald Heifetz of Harvard Kennedy School draws the distinction that explains most digital failures. Technical problems can be solved with existing know-how: buy the system, configure it, train people. Adaptive challenges require people to change their values, habits and relationships. And nobody can do that for them.

    Digital transformation is almost always sold as the first and is almost always the second. Introducing an AI tool is technical. Getting a team to trust a system's recommendation over the most senior person in the room is adaptive. Moving decisions to where the data sits: adaptive. Accepting that a junior analyst sees things the division head doesn't: deeply adaptive.

    When leaders treat an adaptive challenge as a technical one, they delegate it. To IT, to the CDO, to a project office. That's the moment the transformation becomes an IT project with a change budget.

    Why data doesn't replace judgement

    There's a second trap on the other side. Some leaders embrace digital so completely that they expect the data to lead for them. Dashboards, KPIs, AI-generated insights: the answer must be in there somewhere.

    Christian Madsbjerg, co-founder of ReD Associates, argues the opposite in Sensemaking. Numbers show what happens, not what it means. Understanding context (why customers behave as they do, how a change feels to the people living through it) remains a human skill. And it's exactly the skill that leadership for digital transformation needs most.

    Ambidextrous leadership

    The frame we work with is ambidextrous leadership: leading with both hands at once.

    The product-centred hand steers the what: digital products, platforms and processes, the roadmap, the architecture, the business case. This hand thinks in releases and value streams.

    The human-centred hand steers the how: the habits, roles, fears and shifts in power that the new product sets off. This hand thinks in trust, meaning and learning.

    Most organisations give the two hands to different people. IT gets the product side, HR gets "change". The transformation falls into the gap between them. Strategic leadership for digital transformation means holding both hands in one leadership team. And ideally in every single leader.

    What changes when leadership actually leads

    It talks about work, not tools. The question isn't "Is the system live?" but "Which decisions are now made differently?"

    It goes first. If the leadership team keeps deciding with slides and gut feel while asking the organisation to become data-driven, everyone sees the gap.

    It moves decisions. Digital speed comes from shorter decision paths. That means giving up control: the hardest step, and the only one no software can take for you.

    It measures adoption, not rollout. A live system is an input. Changed behaviour is the result.

    The current wave: AI

    Everything above applies twice over to artificial intelligence. AI tools are cheap to buy and quick to roll out. What they demand of leaders (trust in machine output, new roles, a new answer to who knows what) is almost entirely adaptive. If you want to know where your organisation stands, our AI Readiness Pulse Check is a good starting point.

    Where to start

    At your next steering committee, replace the milestone report with a single question: which way of working has changed, for which people, since last month? If nobody can answer, you're funding a caterpillar.

    If your digital transformation could be delegated entirely to IT, it wouldn't be a transformation. It would be a procurement project.

    FAQ

    Frequently Asked Questions

    Sources

    • McKinsey & Company: "Unlocking success in digital transformations", McKinsey Global Survey (2018)
    • Ronald A. Heifetz, Alexander Grashow, Marty Linsky: The Practice of Adaptive Leadership (2009)
    • Christian Madsbjerg: Sensemaking. The Power of the Humanities in the Age of the Algorithm (2017)
    • George Westerman, Didier Bonnet, Andrew McAfee: Leading Digital (2014)