Executive coaching: when it helps and how to start
What executive leadership coaching really changes, what it doesn't, and why the answer lies outside the coaching room.

In short: Executive coaching works. Meta-analyses show positive average effects on skills, attitudes and individual results. Whether it carries a transformation, though, depends less on the coach than on the connection to the organisation. Coaching treated as a private perk changes the person and leaves the system untouched. Coaching that's agreed with the sponsor and tied to what the transformation needs from this leader can change both.
There are two moments when companies typically buy executive coaching. When someone is about to be promoted. And when someone is about to be shown the door.
Reward or repair. Either way, the coaching happens behind a closed door, with a confidentiality agreement and no connection to the strategy everyone else is working on. Six months later, the executive has had some good conversations. The organisation around them hasn't noticed a thing.
That's not a coaching problem. It's a contracting problem.
What is executive coaching?
Executive coaching, often called leadership coaching, is a time-limited, confidential working relationship between a leader and a coach. It works on a real leadership situation: a decision, a role, a relationship or a behaviour that needs to change. The work combines reflection, candid feedback and practising new behaviour in that same situation. Executive coaching makes sense when a concrete goal can be named and the organisation is willing to support the change.
What to agree before you commission coaching
A good brief fits on one page. Before the first session, agree on:
- Goal: an observable leadership situation, for example how the leader prepares decisions in the leadership team, not "better communication".
- Fit and approach: an introductory conversation, how the coach works and whether the working relationship is right.
- Roles: what the leader brings, what the coach is responsible for and what the sponsor will change around them.
- Confidentiality and reporting: session content stays with the coachee; what is shared about goals and progress is agreed by all three in advance.
- Practice between sessions: concrete everyday situations in which the new behaviour is tried out.
- Progress review: agreed points at which all three look at progress and adjust or close the engagement.
The duration follows from the goal, the starting point and these review points, not from a standard package. As external professional guidance, the International Coaching Federation (ICF) Code of Ethics also describes agreeing roles, confidentiality and the release of information clearly with clients and sponsors. How we connect coaching with leadership team development is described under Leadership Transformation.
Does executive coaching work? Yes. Just not the way it's sold.
The evidence is clearer than the critics think and less spectacular than the sellers claim. A meta-analysis by Rebecca Jones, Stephen Woods and Yves Guillaume (2016) pooled 17 studies of workplace coaching, excluding coaching by line managers or peers. The result: positive average effects across outcomes. On skills, on attitudes and motivation, and most strongly on individual results. An earlier meta-analysis by Tim Theeboom and colleagues (2014) reached a similar conclusion for individual performance, well-being and goal-directed self-regulation.
Two details in the Jones study deserve more attention than they get. Effects were stronger with internal coaches than with external ones, a finding from the studies reviewed rather than a universal purchasing rule. And there was no significant difference between face-to-face coaching and blended coaching with e-coaching elements; that doesn't show exclusively online coaching to be equivalent. Nor did the analysis find a clear link between the number of sessions and the effect.
One plausible reading: what matters is less the setting, the duration or the big name. What matters is proximity to the actual work.
And the 500 or 700 percent ROI figures in coaching brochures? Many rest on coachees estimating the financial value of their own coaching. That's worth something. It isn't evidence.
Why a surgeon hired a coach
In 2011, the surgeon and writer Atul Gawande described in The New Yorker why he had hired a coach: a retired surgeon he respected, who stood in his operating room and watched. Gawande wasn't bad at his job. He was good, and he had stopped getting better. His coach saw things Gawande couldn't see from inside his own hands.
That's the tradition executive coaching should come from: sport, music, surgery. Top performers have coaches not because they're broken, but because nobody can watch themselves perform.
Coaching as repair turns that logic on its head. It tells the executive: something is wrong with you. Coaching as a transformation lever says: what we're asking of you is new, and nobody gets there alone.
The snap-back problem
Here's how coaching executives often plays out in the middle of a transformation. The leader works hard on a new way of leading: delegating more, deciding less on gut feel, involving the team earlier. Then they return to a system that still rewards the old way. The steering committee wants certainty. The board wants the numbers by Friday. Peers on the leadership team still compete for budget.
Within weeks, the new behaviour has snapped back. Not because the coaching failed. Because the system won.
Svenja Hofert, one of the sharpest voices on coaching in the German-speaking world, went as far as titling a book Hört auf zu coachen! (Stop coaching!). Her argument isn't against coaching as such, but against the toolbox mindset that treats everyone the same and ignores where a person actually stands in their development. The same applies to the organisation. Coaching that ignores the system a person returns to is a well-meant detour.
The triangle: coaching with a line into the system
The frame we work with is simple: the triangle. Every executive coaching engagement has three parties: the coachee, the coach and the sponsor, usually the line manager or CEO. Transactional analysis has called this the three-cornered contract since the 1970s. Most companies still run coaching as a two-way arrangement.
The triangle makes three things explicit at the start.
What does the transformation need from this leader that it isn't getting today? Not "better communication". Something observable.
What will the people around them notice after six months if the coaching works? This question alone turns a private matter into an organisational one.
What will the sponsor change in the system so that the new behaviour can survive? If the answer is "nothing", save the budget.
Confidentiality stays intact. The content of the sessions belongs to the coachee. The goals don't.
When leadership coaching speeds up transformation
Leadership coaching pays off most in transitions: a new role, a merger, a strategy that asks leaders to give up exactly what made them successful. In those moments, the leader's own behaviour is the most visible signal of whether the change is meant seriously. People don't read the strategy paper. They watch what the boss does on Tuesday.
That's why coaching at the top of a transformation isn't a perk. It's one of the cheapest ways to make change credible.
Where to start
Before you sign the next coaching engagement, hold a 30-minute triangle conversation with the coachee, the coach and the sponsor. Answer the three questions above in writing. Meet again, all three of you, at the halfway point and at the end.
If nobody around the coached executive notices a difference after six months, it wasn't coaching. It was an expensive diary.
FAQ
Frequently Asked Questions
Sources
- Rebecca J. Jones, Stephen A. Woods, Yves R. F. Guillaume: "The effectiveness of workplace coaching: a meta-analysis of learning and performance outcomes from coaching", Journal of Occupational and Organizational Psychology 89(2), 2016
- Tim Theeboom, Bianca Beersma, Annelies E. M. van Vianen: "Does coaching work? A meta-analysis on the effects of coaching on individual level outcomes in an organizational context", The Journal of Positive Psychology 9(1), 2014
- Atul Gawande: "Personal Best", The New Yorker (2011)
- Svenja Hofert: Hört auf zu coachen! Wie man Menschen wirklich weiterbringt (Kösel)
- Fanita English: "The Three-Cornered Contract", Transactional Analysis Journal (1975)
- International Coaching Federation: ICF Code of Ethics, sections 1.1 and 2.2
