Skip to main content
    Leadership

    The 70% Myth: Why Change Doesn't Fail Where You Think It Does

    Leadership and change management aren't the same thing. Confusing the two is exactly where change goes wrong.

    Daniel MartiDaniel Marti·7 min read
    The 70% Myth: Why Change Doesn't Fail Where You Think It Does – Leadership and transformation
    In short: The claim that 70 percent of change initiatives fail has no reliable empirical basis, as Mark Hughes showed in 2011. The myth survives because it's convenient: it makes failure normal and puts the blame on "resistance". In practice, change rarely fails because of employees. It fails when leadership manages change instead of leading it: when leaders plan, communicate and roll out, but don't change their own behaviour first.

    You know the number. Probably from a kick-off. Maybe from a consulting proposal. "70 percent of all change initiatives fail."

    It's one of the most quoted statistics in management. It's also one without a credible source.

    In 2011, Mark Hughes of Brighton Business School traced the five most prominent publications behind the 70 percent figure, among them Hammer and Champy, Beer and Nohria, and John Kotter. His finding: there is no valid and reliable empirical evidence to support it.

    Even Kotter's version is broader than most people assume. In A Sense of Urgency (2008), he counted change as failed if it was never launched, never completed, or finished late, over budget and short of its original aims. By that definition, almost anything complex fails.

    Why the myth is so comfortable

    A number that everyone quotes and nobody checks is usually doing a job. This one does two.

    It makes failure normal. If seven out of ten fail anyway, nobody needs to ask why ours did.

    And it points the finger downwards. The next sentence is almost always about "resistance to change": employees who won't move, middle managers who block, a culture that eats strategy for breakfast.

    A line often attributed to Peter Senge gets closer to the truth: people don't resist change. They resist being changed.

    Change management is not change leadership

    John Kotter, whose eight-step model remains one of the most useful maps for transformation, draws a distinction that many organisations miss. Change management is a set of processes and tools for keeping change under control: plans, communication cascades, training, stakeholder maps. Change leadership is the force that drives change: urgency, direction, and people who go first.

    Most organisations are very good at the first and nearly absent in the second. They build the plan, fill the intranet, hold the town hall. Then the leadership team goes back to its meeting room and decides exactly the way it did before.

    The organisation doesn't read the plan. It watches its leaders.

    Frederic Laloux put it bluntly in Reinventing Organizations: an organisation can't evolve beyond its leadership's stage of development. Niels Pfläging makes the point from the other side, from a systems perspective: you can't change people by programme. You change the system they work in, and people change themselves. That system is shaped by leadership.

    Prosci's long-running research on change management points the same way. Across its studies, active and visible sponsorship from senior leaders is named, again and again, as the single biggest contributor to success.

    The 16% logic

    If change doesn't fail at the bottom, where should leadership focus? Not on convincing everybody.

    In the 1940s, the sociologists Bryce Ryan and Neal Gross studied how Iowa farmers adopted hybrid seed corn. Their study later became one of the foundations of Everett Rogers' Diffusion of Innovations. The pattern has held in hundreds of studies since: new practices spread through people, not announcements. First a small group tries something out, the innovators (around 2.5 percent) and the early adopters (13.5 percent). The majority follows once it sees the new thing working for people it trusts.

    2.5 plus 13.5 makes 16. That's what we call the 16% logic. Change leadership isn't about winning everyone over. It's about finding, protecting and making visible the 16 percent who are already moving. And letting them do what no town hall can: show that it works.

    That's why we talk about campaigning rather than rolling out. A rollout pushes a plan onto everyone at once. A campaign wins people over, group by group, starting with those most ready to move. In our work, the middle phase of every transformation is called Campaigning for exactly that reason, between Diagnostics and Embedding.

    What leaders do when they lead change

    They go first, visibly. The first change in behaviour happens in the leadership team, not in the organisation.

    They find the 16 percent. Who already works the new way? Who's experimenting without permission? Those are your change agents, not necessarily the people with a formal change role.

    They stop pouring energy into the laggards. The late majority moves when the early majority does. Arguing with sceptics mostly makes them better at arguing.

    They treat resistance as information. Objections show what the plan overlooked. Listening to them is cheaper than overriding them.

    Where to start

    At your next leadership team meeting, ask one question: what have we personally stopped doing since the change began? If the list is empty, you've found the reason your change is stuck. It isn't in the organisation. It's in the room.

    The question isn't whether your people are ready for change. It's whether your leaders are ready to be seen changing first.

    FAQ

    Frequently Asked Questions

    Sources

    • Mark Hughes: "Do 70 Per Cent of All Organizational Change Initiatives Really Fail?", Journal of Change Management 11(4), 2011
    • John P. Kotter: Leading Change (1996); A Sense of Urgency (2008)
    • Everett M. Rogers: Diffusion of Innovations (1962)
    • Bryce Ryan, Neal C. Gross: "The Diffusion of Hybrid Seed Corn in Two Iowa Communities", Rural Sociology (1943)
    • Frederic Laloux: Reinventing Organizations (2014)
    • Prosci: Best Practices in Change Management