The Leader as Coach: Why Better Questions Aren't Enough
Cultivating leaders as coaches is one of the most effective ways to build internal development. Most organisations go about it the wrong way round.

In short: Leaders who coach develop their people faster and keep them longer. Google's Project Oxygen found "is a good coach" to be the top behaviour of its best managers. But a manager can never coach as neutrally as an external coach: they set goals, give feedback and decide on pay. The leader-as-a-coach role works when it's understood as developmental leadership, closer to a master with an apprentice than to a therapist. And it only lasts if the organisation makes room for it.
You know the question. "What do you think, wouldn't it make sense to call the client first?"
It sounds like coaching. It's an instruction in disguise. And everyone in the room knows it.
That's often what comes out of two-day coaching courses for managers: a set of open questions, the GROW model on a laminated card, and a slightly uneasy feeling on both sides of the table. The employee doesn't know whether they're being asked or tested. The manager doesn't know whether they're still allowed to say what they think.
Why every company wants leaders as coaches
The case is strong. When Google set out to show that managers don't matter, its Project Oxygen found the opposite, and the first of the eight behaviours of its best managers was simply: is a good coach. Gallup attributes at least 70 percent of the variance in team engagement to the manager.
In a world where skills age faster than job descriptions, development can't wait for the annual training catalogue. It has to happen where the work happens: in the team, every week, through the person who sees the work.
So far, so right. The trouble starts with what organisations do next.
The coaching-course trap
Most programmes try to turn managers into coaches by teaching them the techniques of professional coaching: open questions, active listening, holding back advice.
The problem: a manager isn't a neutral coach and never will be. They set targets. They evaluate. They decide on salaries and promotions. A coaching conversation with your own boss is never free of that. Pretending otherwise produces exactly those disguised instructions. And, worse, a slow erosion of trust.
Herminia Ibarra and Anne Scoular described the way out in Harvard Business Review in 2019. Leaders move along a spectrum, from directive (telling, advising, teaching) to non-directive (listening, asking, letting the person find their own answer), and choose deliberately depending on the person and the situation. They call it situational coaching. The skill isn't asking questions. It's knowing when a question helps and when it's just a way of avoiding a clear answer.
Master, not therapist
Switzerland has a tradition that fits better than any coaching model: the apprenticeship. Around two thirds of young people in Switzerland learn their profession through vocational education and training, guided by a workplace trainer in the middle of real work.
A good master doesn't pretend to be neutral. They show how it's done. They let the apprentice do it. They ask what happened. They correct. And step by step they hand over responsibility, until the apprentice no longer needs them.
That's the frame we work with: the master sequence. Show. Let do. Reflect. Hand over.
It's a coaching stance with the honesty of a leader. The master has an opinion and shares it. They also know when to keep it to themselves, so the other person can find their own way. And the goal is explicit from day one: independence.
The neurobiologist Gerald Hüther puts the underlying point plainly. You can't change people from the outside. You can only invite, encourage and inspire them to change themselves. The master sequence is an invitation with a structure.
What organisations must do so leaders can coach
A coaching management style rarely fails on skill. It fails on the calendar.
A manager with twelve direct reports, a full operational load and eight meetings a day will not coach, however good the course was. If you want leaders as coaches, the organisation has to make three things true.
Time. Development conversations need protected time, and spans of control have to allow for it.
Recognition. If promotions go to the best individual performers, managers will keep performing individually. Make "people who grew under you" part of how leaders are assessed.
Peers. Leaders learn to coach by coaching each other. Collegial case consultation (Kollegiale Beratung, a structured peer-advice format widely used in German-speaking organisations) is one of the most underrated development tools there is: small groups, a fixed process, a real case, no trainer required.
That's what fostering internal development really means. Not a coaching certificate for every manager, but a system in which developing people is part of the job rather than a favour on top of it.
Where to start
Pick one recurring decision you currently make yourself. Over the next six weeks, hand it to someone on your team using the master sequence: let them watch you decide once, decide it together once, then let them decide and review it together. Then step back.
One decision. Six weeks. You'll learn more about coaching than in any course.
And then the question for the organisation: are your leaders allowed to spend time on this, or do they have to steal it?
FAQ
Frequently Asked Questions
Sources
- Google re:Work: Project Oxygen
- Gallup: State of the American Manager (2015)
- Herminia Ibarra, Anne Scoular: "The Leader as Coach", Harvard Business Review (November–December 2019)
- State Secretariat for Education, Research and Innovation (SERI): Vocational and Professional Education and Training in Switzerland – Facts and Figures
